McCoy Insurance Agency, Inc.

"Family Owned Business for over Five Generations"


Thank you for visiting us at our newly rejuvenated website. As a modern business, we want you to have the opportunity to keep in touch with our company and our specialties. This simply formatted website will enable us to keep you updated and in touch with what we have to offer.

About Us

We have remained a family owned business since we opened our doors in 1910.

J. Matthew McCoy is the owner of the agency in addition to farming grain and livestock full-time as part of J. McCoy Farms LLC.

Our office is situated at the edge of the beautiful family farm.

With the help of a dedicated full-time staff, we do our best to emphasize personal relationships and care for our insureds.


Click the icons to see what we offer


Covers a wide range of properties including

homes, contents, rentals and vacant properties;

Multi-policy discounts available


Affordable Income Replacement

Allows peace-of-mind for loved ones

3 types: Term, Universal, and Whole Life

Contact Lisa Lankford for a quote


Agency specialty!

Company owner Matthew McCoy is a full-time farmer

Grain, cattle, dairy, and other livestock options


Personal auto coverage with competitive rates;

Multi-policy discounts available


Protect your business assets

In case of disaster we will quickly put you back in business

3 types: Liability, Property, and Auto


Excess liability coverage over and above

underlying policy liability limits

3 types: Personal, Commercial, and Farm


McCoy Insurance Agency has achieved the following awards with
Wayne Insurance Group based on growth and sales:

2018-Present Platinum

2013-2017 Diamond

2012 Silver

2005-2010 Gold

We work with a variety of Companies to provide quality insurance products at an affordable price

Wayne Insurance Group | Western Reserve Group | Auto-Owners | Progressive | Foremost | Wyandot Mutual | Hagerty | Norton Mutual


Contact us to learn what we can do for you!

5062 Friendsville Rd | Wooster, Ohio 44691

(330) 345-7220

1 (877) 320-7220

(330) 345-4177 (fax)

Our Staff

J. Matthew McCoy, President/Owner/Agent
(330) 345-7220

Lisa Lankford, Office Manager/Agent
(330) 345-7220 | Email

Jodie Seager, Agent
(330) 345-7220 | Email

Linda Demiter, Agent
(330) 345-7220 | Email


We are located on Friendsville Road just past the Smithville-Western Road intersection