By completing this claim form you have only summitted the claim directly to the McCoy Insurance Agency Team, not the company. We will be in contact with you during regular business hours. If you need to report a claim immediately, please call the company directly with the below contact information: 

Auto Owner: 1-888-252-4626

Foremost 1-800-572-3905

Hagerty 1-800-385-0274

Liberty Mutual: 1-800-225-2467 

Progressive 1-800-274-4499

Wayne Mutual: 1-800-222-3873

Western Reserve 1-800-362-0426

Wyandot Mutual: 419-294-2862

1859 Mutual: 419-849-2521

​